We are just as barbaric as Trump

We are just as barbaric as Trump
By Zan Azlee

In the past week or so, people all around the world, Malaysians included, have been shocked by US President Donald Trump’s migration separation policy.

Under his administration’s policy, adults who are illegal immigrants in the US would be detained and processed. And if they have children, these children are taken away and put under state custody.

The world’s media have been flooded by photos and videos of these children – some newborns and infants – being kept in metal cages. In some videos, you can see and even hear these children crying and screaming for their parents.

Any human being with a conscience would be horrified at such an action. Of course, Trump and his administration are facing heavy criticism over this issue. Unfortunately, Trump is just being Trump and he doesn’t care. For all you know, he might even say these reports are fake news.

What is also surprising to me is that Malaysians are so shocked and angry at all that is happening in the US that they forget that situations like these have been happening in their own backyard for decades. And what has been happening here not only involves illegal immigrants but much worse – refugees.

Hundreds of thousands of Rohingya have been flooding our shores looking for a safe haven for more than 30 years. And according to a recent Suhakam report, more than 100 foreign immigration detainees have died in Malaysia between 2015 and 2017. Half of them are from Myanmar, where the Rohingya come from.

Everyone has to be familiar with the Rohingya exodus. If you aren’t, then that coconut shell that you’re living in must be one hell of a nuclear bunker.

It is the largest ethnic cleansing in the world right now and millions of Rohingya have already been chased out of their villages. Bangladesh has seen most entering their borders with over million now living in the Kutupalong Refugee Camp at the border town of Cox’s Bazar. Aside from Bangladesh, Malaysia is up there as one of the countries that have seen a large influx of fleeing Rohingya.

It is also surprising to me that so many Malaysians don’t even know that the Malaysian government is not a signatory to the 1951 UN Refugee Convention. What that means is that we do not recognise refugees and when these people come into the country looking for help, the authorities see them as illegal immigrants.

And when they are categorised as illegal immigrants, they can be detained, put in jail, and then deported back to where they came from. In the Rohingya’s case, this means they will be sent back to the place where they have been oppressed, tortured and killed by the Myanmar government.

There have also been many cases where one, or even both, parents are caught by authorities and detained. This leaves their children abandoned and forced to fend for themselves. For those who are lucky enough to escape being caught, they face a situation where they can’t work, go to school or have access to healthcare.

Time to do things differently

This sounds similar to what is going on in the US and with the Trump administration, isn’t it? Our last government, the BN administration, was always adamant that Malaysia would never sign the Refugee Convention and would never recognise refugees.

But now, with Malaysia Baru, where we now have an administration that, for the past two decades, has been screaming for freedom, equality and human rights, I am expecting that this previous selfish attitude of the government will change and something will be done to address the situation of the refugees.

All we need to do is recognise them as refugees, legalise them and provide them with basic human rights. In the US, Trump and his people claim that illegal immigrants are the cause of social ills and all kinds of crime. That’s what many ignorant Malaysians argue too.

If they are allowed to work, then that in itself will take them off the black market. So, that is the solution to social ills and crime. Now, many will also say that these immigrants will steal jobs from the locals. But be realistic. They take on jobs that most locals wouldn’t even consider doing.

At least when they are allowed to work legally, they get to provide for their families, feed them, give them an education and have access to healthcare. Quite directly, this would even contribute towards the local economy because they are now earning and spending money legitimately.

But then ignorant critics will also claim that they send money out of the country because they will want to help their families back home. Okay, so what is the problem with that? They would already be a part of our local economy. How significant would their outflow be anyway? It’s really a win-win situation for them and for us.

All I am saying is that we shouldn’t just be shocked at what is happening around us and horrified at how barbaric we have become. We need to do something and at this point in time, we can make it known to the Pakatan Harapan government that this is one of the many things that we Malaysians feel passionate about.

ZAN AZLEE is a writer, documentary filmmaker, journalist and academic. His latest documentary film ‘We Are Animals’ will be premiering at the Refugee Festival this Thursday, June 28, 2018, at the Black Box in Publika. It is about life in Kutupalong, the world’s largest refugee camp in Bangladesh.

[This article was originally written for and published at Malaysiakini.com]

Get Zan Azlee’s latest book ‘JOURNO-DAD: The chronicles of a journalist who just happens to be a dad!‘ today!


Buy more Fat Bidin books, films and merchandise at The Fat Bidin Store!



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s